Thats funny i feel like it worked really well for me after my last cut. Slowly building up calories instead of just jumping up to a 2000 calorie surplus. I was definitely much leaner as opposed to the traditional bulk i would normally do before. Curious to why you say that doc.
Most people that follow it are competitors after a show. The problem is that it's serving no real physiological need but only psychological ones since aesthetic competitors tend to obsess over quick weight gains but the weight gains are mostly water and glycogen. It can actually be harmful for women competitors as it can permanently stop their menstrual cycle. Now, if you only spend a couple weeks doing it it's not that big of a deal but there are people out there reverse dieting for months on end. Here's a post from a good buddy MrRippedzilla on the topic
That's exactly what it is and yes, its wrong.
Reverse dieting = slowly adding calories back, over a period of months, after a cut/show until you reach maintenance.
It is a popular approach for competitors who obsess over the slightest weight gain (even if its just water) and live in a fantasy world of maintaining show-ready conditioning. This mentally applies to most competitors, especially women, so you can see why reverse dieting is popular - it feeds their psychological needs.
The problem is, psychological needs
do not dictate physiological realities.
By reverse dieting all your really doing is staying in a deficit for an extended period of time and DELAYING your recovery. For men - hormone levels are not going to ****ing return to normal until you reach maintenance. For women - same thing plus the major ****ing issue of amenorrhoea, which takes a long time to recover anyway but by reverse dieting your making the situation worse. Getting to maintenance is an absolute necessity for physical recovery and there is no way around this beyond drug use - that's why this reverse dieting bullshit is a major pain in my ass.
This entire concept was created by Layne Norton and his butt buddies, who manage to make a shitload of cash through it by the way, and then a bunch of other "coaches" followed suite because they can't differentiate their assess from their mouths and must follow whatever is trending. Of course these "coaches" benefited greatly because it allowed them to generate more money by promoting "reversediet plans" or "recovery dietphases" and making clients keep them hired for longer periods of time. Bunch of money hungry mother****ers.
And then you have coaches like myself and POB who don't promote bullshit.
I'll let POB speak for himself since I'm not sure how common a trend this is in the PLing world but when it comes to BBing its a major pain in my ass. I spend so long trying to help these folks, mostly women, recover from neglectful care while also trying
EDUCATE them because THAT is how your supposed to deal with both the psychological needs + physiological realities.
We spend, at most, 2 weeks getting back up to maintenance so that everything physical recovers as soon as possible and the rest of the time its mostly behavioral therapy focused on reducing the weight/aesthetic/food obsession and making it part of a bigger picture. Of course this is hard work and doesn't provide any short term results, which is why most coaches don't even bother with it - who cares about what your clients need when you can just line your pockets up with more cash right? ****ers.
I know I'm going way off now but I cannot emphasize enough the importance of behavioral therapy for competitors.
One of the reasons you don't see these behavioral issues with PLers as much is because you guys are focused on a HEALTHY long term goal - getting stronger, bodybuilding is focused on getting super shredded for 1 show, which is not a health or long term goal in any way shape or form.
So I spend a lot of time of helping these folks creating a goal-setting mindset that isn't necessarily revolving around food/looks so that they have that feeling of control & freedom - 2 key attributes to avoiding eating disorders & body dysmorphia. The idea is to create mindful acceptance, habits involving taking positive action vs stress and, most importantly of all, eliminating the obsessive tendencies that run rampant in this community.
This stuff is hard work but worth it in the long run. Not only do you see these clients grow, personal growth, but also develop much healthier relationships all round (with food, family, partners, life in general) and it
does benefit their competitive careers too because you'll see most competitors tell you that their best preps are the least stressful - not a coincidental association.
TL;DR - reverse dieting is bullshit created to make money for coaches and hurt (physically) clients. Now I'm off for a drink to calm my ass down.
As opposed to just jumping to a large calorie surplus i simply add calories over time. What works for me while running aas and taking full advantage of the metabolic increase is 200 calories per week. You can adjust that depending on how you respond but thats just what i do. The goal is to increase your calories as your metabolism adjust to the new heightened caloric intake. Some people do the layne norton style but as an enhanced athlete i feel like we could take more that just 50 or 100 cals a week. It takes a few months to build up but i saw a vast difference in my physique as opposed to a traditional bulk would bring. Do the gains come slower? Yes. But you end up putting on far less bodyfat which makes cutting next time far easier. I think that is the biggest advantage with reverse dieting i found. In 3 months time you'll be in a caloric surplus and you just keep adding cals till you reach a point of diminishing return.
You could get the same results with just minimizing the size of your calorie surplus.