Four American Civilians Killed in Iraq Shooting

garyzilla

New Member
BAGHDAD, Iraq (March 16) -- Hours after four U.S. missionaries were slain in a drive-by shooting in the northern city of Mosul, the top U.S. military commander said Tuesday that such attacks were meant to divide the 36-member coalition occupying Iraq.

U.S. Army Lt. Gen. Ricardo Sanchez also cast doubt on whether Spain would withdraw its 1,300 troops from Iraq, but added that if they do, the loss would not be ''a significant military problem'' for the U.S.-led coalition.

''I think that it is still evolving,'' Sanchez said. ''We will have to wait a few days.''

The death toll in the attack on five Baptist missionaries rose to four on Tuesday after one of the injured died while being flown to a military hospital in Baghdad, the U.S. military said.

A fifth American was being treated at a U.S. military hospital in Mosul.

''Clearly there has been a shift in the insurgency and the way the extremists are conducting operations,'' Sanchez said during a military ceremony in the northern city of Tikrit. ''It is very clear they are going after these targets that might create some splits within the coalition.''

The five Baptist missionaries were on a humanitarian mission when two or three men attacked them from a neighboring car, witnesses said.

The Virginia-based Southern Baptist International Mission Board identified the four dead as Larry T. Elliott, 60, and Jean Dover Elliott, 58, of Cary, N.C.; Karen Denise Watson, 38, of Bakersfield, Calif.; and David E. McDonnall, 28, of Rowlett, Texas.

McDonnall died Tuesday morning on a helicopter that was transporting him to a military hospital in Baghdad after four U.S. military surgeons worked for six hours to save his life, the mission board said.

McDonnall's wife, Carrie Taylor McDonnall, 26, of Rowlett, Texas, remains in critical condition, the mission board said. She is the only survivor of the attack.

Lt. Col. Joseph Piek, a spokesman for American forces in Mosul, said the five Americans were traveling in one car on the eastern side of the city when they were attacked.

An off-duty Iraqi policeman found the car shortly after the late Monday afternoon shooting. Three of the victims were dead. The officer took the two wounded to an Iraqi hospital. U.S. Army air medical evacuation helicopters later transported them to a combat support hospital in Mosul.

The Elliotts were scouting the best location for a water purification project, said Michelle DeVoss of the First Baptist Church in Cary, N.C.

''They knew going into Iraq, they couldn't really share their Christian faith unless somebody asked them,'' said Larry Kingsley, a church deacon. ''They were there in a humanitarian situation. They were people who just had a great heart for helping people out.''

The five knew they were traveling to a dangerous part of the world, but decided to press on, said Manda Roten, spokeswoman for the missionary board.

''Their personal love for God and their desire to obey him would outweigh any personal risks for them,'' Roten said. ''When you think about overseas service, and when you sense God calling you to go overseas, safety isn't the primary concern.''

Iraqi police and the FBI were involved in the investigation.

In Mosul on Tuesday, an Iraqi woman whose sister works for the U.S. military was slain in a drive-by shooting that also wounded the woman's brother and father, police in the city said. Police said the slain woman, a pharmacist, may have been confused with her sister who works as a translator on a U.S. Army base in Mosul.

In the southern city of Kufa on Tuesday, 1,000 college students protested the signing of Iraq's recently approved interim constitution. The demonstrators decried Iraqi Governing Council members who approved the document as ''U.S. agents'' and burned American, British and Israeli flags.

In Mosul on Sunday, guerrillas raked a government convoy with gunfire, killing the regional secretary of labor and social affairs and his driver, U.S. Brig. Gen. Mark Kimmitt said.

In Spain, the newly elected prime minister promised to withdraw the country's 1,300 troops from Iraq by June 30 unless the United Nations assumes control of peacekeeping.

Sanchez said the coalition could continue without Spain's contribution.

''It is something we will have to adjust to,'' the general said. ''But it is clearly manageable. It is not a significant military problem for the coalition to be able to cover that area.''

The new prime minister, Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero, vowed to pull out Spanish forces during the election campaign. The United States plans to turn over sovereignty to Iraq by June 30 but has no plans to cede control of the military operation to the United Nations.

Zapatero's Socialist party was propelled to an upset victory in elections Sunday by anger over terrorist attacks in Madrid last week that killed 200 people. Voters accused the outgoing prime minister, Jose Maria Aznar, of making Spain a target by supporting the U.S.-led war in Iraq.

Eleven Spaniards have died in Iraq since August, including seven intelligence agents killed in an ambush in late November.
 
First, that is just tragic. American civilians are being killed because they gave a damn about the welfare of the Iraqi people. Sometimes I think that we Americans should just pull out our food, support and security just like the Iraqi people want. I think they should just rot and starve in that shithole of a desert country.

I dont think the Iraqi people want Democracy myself. Their country has never known what it means to have a democracy. To have a democracy, there must be a foundation. That foundation is that EVERYONE IS EQUAL UNDER THE LAW. The Iraqi people do not believe that. Basically, the people who were being oppressed (the Shi'ites) now want all the power in order to payback the oppressors. THEY DONT WANT DEMOCRACY, AND IT WONT WORK. Their culture is not hospitable to the ideal of equality.

Also, no offense to any Christians, but I am just saying what I think many are thinking. Being a Christian missionary in Iraq, what did you think was going to happen to you? You think a country with almost no law that consists mostly of Muslims with guns is going to allow a bunch of white people to run around talking about Christ? That is like holding the dynamite and lighting the fuse...Are you surprised it blew up?

Let me clarify that THIS SHOULD NOT HAVE HAPPENED. IT IS DEPLORABLE. However, it just proves my point above. Iraq does not see all people as equal. They were offended by the white Christians, so what did they do? Defend their right to be different? Nope. They just murdered them. Thats why democracy in Iraq wont work. Because Christians are murdered, women are beaten and degraded, and "American Freedom" is mocked.

I just wish people could see that this democratic experiment is doomed to fail.
 
Mark, if the missionaries were killed by normal Iraqi citizens, then I would agree wholeheartedly with your analysis. But I would bet that the attackers were of the same sort as teh terrorists. Of course the terrorists dont want progress, whether political or religious, in Iraq. They have had absolute power for what, 15 or 20 years under Saddam?

A top al Queda officer was killed today or yesterday. Was just announced on the news.
 
I do see your point Bob, and I actually do agree. So this begs the question:

Do you think the average Iraqi citizen supports democracy, supports American occupation, sees all religions as deserving equal rights and sees all citizens as deserving equal rights? (P.S. You can answer each part of this question, I dont think it is an all or nothing question)

I dont think the average citizen does, but I have never asked one or been to Iraq.

Also, Iraq has NEVER known democracy. They have been ruled by either a monarchy or dictorship for the past 5000 years.
 
Back
Top