Fad diets.Why they dont work in the long term

Desibaba

New Member
Diets

Many people want something for nothing. This attitude also applies to those wishing to lose body fat, gain muscle, and improve their physical fitness or sports performance. There is no miracle means to good nutritional practices. With thousands of foods to choose from, you can easily see how many diets can exist using different food combinations and dieting angles. However, upon close examination, many of these trendy diets may be deficient in important macro- and -micronutrients. Most of these diets do not provide adequate nutrition and therefore are not meant for individuals who are on a fitness or athletic training program. Fad weight-loss diets can be too low in protein or carbohydrates, and some of them are too high in fat. They can also leave the dieter in a poor state of health, with a damaged metabolism. Typically, the weight lost from fad dieting consists of water weight, fat, and muscle mass. This loss of muscle mass is where the problem exists, because it reduces the body's ability to burn calories. When the fad dieter has lost weight, their body has a lower capacity to burn calories. As most dieters soon return to their old eating habits, they tend to gain more weight as body fat and can end up having a higher percentage of body fat, even if they do not return to their previous high weight.

Carbohydrate-Restricted Diets

Fad diets almost always severely cut carbohydrate foods from their lists of recommended consumption. Not only does this sap your energy, it can also harm athletic performance. The fact is, you need carbohydrates for your brain, heart, and muscles, among other vital organs. The main fuel of the brain and central nervous system is glucose, which is most easily obtained from carbohydrates. If carbohydrates remain unavailable for several days the body attempts to conserve essential protein by producing an alternative fuel source known as ketones, made from the partial burning of fatty acids. As the breakdown continues, these ketones build in the blood causing an abnormal condition called ketosis. Initial weight loss is NOT fat but water, as the kidneys attempt to rid the body of excess ketones. Ketogenic diets make the blood more acidic, upsetting the body's chemical balance and causing potentially serious and unpleasant side effects like headaches, bad breath, dizziness, fatigue, and nausea. In addition, fat can only be metabolized via Krebs cycle oxidation. It is essential to recognize that a reduction in Krebs cycle intermediates due to low- or no-carbohydrate diets will result in a diminished rate of ATP production from fat metabolism. When carbohydrate stores are depleted in the body, the rate at which fat is metabolized is reduced. Carbohydrates are therefore essential in the ability to metabolize fat. It is only the free fatty acids that are metabolized via the Krebs cycle that are used in ATP production, that go toward reducing body fat levels during exercise.

It is true that a large volume of weight will be lost as glycogen (stored carbohydrate) depletes in the muscles and liver, but this weight is from water loss. This will not help body composition or overall health. It is also true that the body will rely more on free fatty acids for fuel when muscle glycogen is depleted, but the body will rely much more on amino acids (protein) supplied from the breakdown of lean tissue. So while you may burn fat, you will also burn more muscle. In addition to this, individuals on a carbohydrate-restricted diet have lower energy levels and experience shorter time to fatigue during exercise. This means that workouts will likely be shorter and lower in intensity.

Protein-Restricted Diets

Diets that drastically cut protein are another culprit in unhealthy eating. Active athletes and fitness enthusiast, you are simply asking for trouble. Muscle soreness, general fatigue and overall weakness accompany low protein consumption.

Although your body appears to be unchanging, it is always in a constant state of flux. Body protein is constantly being turned over as old cells die and new cells replace them. Science has proven that 98% of the atoms in your body are replaced within one year. In three months, your body produces an entirely new skeleton. Every six weeks, all the cells have been replaced in your liver. You have a new stomach lining every five days. Every month you produce an entirely new skin as dead cells are shed and new cells grow underneath. The proteins in your muscles are continually turned over as muscle is broken down and new tissue is synthesized. Every cell in your body is constantly being recycled. Where do all these new cells come from? These new cells come from the protein you consume every day.

The fate of an amino acid after it is transported to the liver is highly dependent on the body's immediate needs. Some amino acids enter the bloodstream, where they join amino acids that have been liberated during the constant breakdown and synthesis of our body's tissues. Each cell, directed by its own DNA blueprint, draws from the common pool of available amino acids to synthesize all the numerous proteins required for its functions.

In order for protein synthesis to occur, an adequate supply of both essential and non-essential amino acids is vital. If one of the essential amino acids is missing, synthesis is halted. Any amino acids that are not used within a short time cannot be stored for future use. Restriction in protein intake will result in protein degradation and muscle breakdown (catabolism).
 
Fat-Restricted Diets

Although diets that notably cut fat intake are usually healthy, is unhealthy to drastically reduce levels of unsaturated fat. Fat acts as a carrier for the four fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, E and K) and it helps to cushion your kidneys, liver and nerves. Research has shown that an extremely limited intake of unsaturated fat can result in elevated cholesterol, a condition that can lead to a heart attack or stroke.

Calorie-Restricted Diets

Since most diets have a limited number of calories per day, it is highly unlikely that full vitamin and mineral replenishment will take place. Even well-balanced diets may not effectively replenish all the vitamins, minerals and foodstuffs used up by athletes in training and competition.

The body's number-one priority is to obtain sufficient energy to carry on vital functions such as circulation, respiration and digestion. Therefore, in the absence of adequate dietary carbohydrates, protein and fat calories, the body will break down not only dietary protein but protein in the blood, liver, pancreas, muscles, and other tissues in order to maintain vital organs and functions.

Without sufficient energy, the human body has the innate ability to break down muscle tissue for use as an energy source during heavy exercise. This process is known as gluconeogenesis, which is the production of glucose from non-carbohydrate sources. The part of the reaction that pertains to our discussion is known as the glucose-alanine cycle. During this cycle, BCAAs (three of the essential amino acids: leucine, isoleucine, and valine) are stripped from the muscle tissue and are converted to the amino acid alanine, which is transported to the liver and converted to glucose. Branched-chained amino acids are metabolized directly in the muscle and can be converted into energy to prevent muscle catabolism.

In addition, low-calorie programs cause side effects similar to ketogenic diets, but with decreased calories medical consequences are more severe. Low-calorie diets should only be administered under careful medical supervision. We do not condone any plans that contain fewer than 1,200 calories.

Common Fad Diets

We are continually barraged with new diet books and programs marketed weekly. Anyone can be successful at weight loss if they eat fewer calories than their bodies need. Since we as future fitness educators cannot rely on the accuracy of claims made by advertisements, key questions should be asked for any given nutritional program.

Does the program integrate physical activity?

Does the program account for personal preferences based on lifestyle and career?

How fast does the program encourage weight loss or muscle gain?

Does the program help change negative behaviors into positive behaviors?

What kind of professional support is provided?

What kind of maintenance program is provided?

We will summarize some of the top selling programs available on the market today and briefly discuss their effectiveness and safety.

The Zone, written by Barry Sears, PhD, (Harper Collins 1995) and Mastering the Zone, released in 1997, are low-carbohydrate, high-protein eating programs. Foods stressed are lean meat, chicken, fish, non-starch vegetables and certain fruits. According to Sears, clients should select food combinations known as blocks that balance fat and protein due to our body's hormonal balance. The premise of the plan is that the majority of Americans have a genetic defect that leads to an overproduction of insulin and that carbohydrates trigger insulin release. This defect produces bad eicosanoids, which are responsible for virtually every disease state. Stanford endocrinologist, Gerald Reaven, whose work is cited in Sears' book, states that there is not evidence that changes in insulin affect eicosanoids or that eating equal amounts of protein and carbohydrates lowers insulin levels. The Zone falls into the category of a low-carbohydrate diet plan.
 
Should You Enter "The Zone?"

You already know that a "40% carbohydrate, 30% protein and 30% fat structure" nutrition plan will not work for everybody. Just like other fad diets, if you follow the plan and eat the prescribed amount of foods, you will probably lose weight. This diet has no place in sports nutrition. Many scientists have written scientific reports, denouncing its use.

The Atkins' New Diet Revolution is a slightly revised version of Dr. Atkins' Diet Revolution. The book, written by Robert C. Atkins MD, claims that overweight people do not overeat but have a disturbance in carbohydrate metabolism. Atkins claims that when carbohydrates are severely limited, the body burns its own fat and hunger is suppressed. During a minimum of a 14-day period at the onset of the program, carbohydrates are restricted to 20 grams per day. The nutrient breakdown is 5% carbohydrates, 35% fat and 60% protein. Average caloric intake is between 1700 to 2300 calories. This plan falls under low-carbohydrate plans and is not recommended for the reasons listed above.

The Fat Blocker Diet, written by Arnold Fox, MD, and Brenda Aderly, MHA, claims that one gram of chitosan will block the absorption of 3 to 6 grams of fat. The positively charged chitosan will attract and bind to negatively charged fat, thereby reducing blood fat, total cholesterol and bad LDL cholesterol while increasing the good HDL cholesterol. The book does provide reliable information based on the Food Guide Pyramid and encourages dieters to exercise. We do not recommend this plan due to the core of the program being based on animal studies.

Fit for Life, written by Marilyn and Harvey Diamond, claims that the body cannot digest more than one concentrated food at a time. The program claims that you cannot eat protein and carbohydrates together because the necessary enzymes for digestion counteract one another, resulting in the food putrefying in your system.You consequently become fat because you cannot break this food down. The program only allows for 20 grams of protein per day and does not allow followers to drink water with meals. Fit for Life falls under a low-protein diet. We do not recommend this plan due to the aforementioned reasons listed in low-protein diets. In addition, diets of this nature can lead to eating disorders because they suppress your metabolism and can lead to food obsessions.

The New Pritkin Diet, written by Robert Pritkin, is based on the low-fat diet developed by his father Nathan Pritkin. The calorie intake for men ranges from 1300 to 1600 calories and, for women, 1200 to 1400. The plan emphasizes a fat intake of 10 percent or less, five to six small meals a day and exercise. This plan falls under low-fat and low-calorie diets and is not recommended for the reasons cited above.

The New Beverly Hills Diet, written by Judy Mazel, is a 35-day plan to lose weight through consuming low-calorie produce and eating food in specified combinations. Followers are required to only eat protein with protein, carbohydrates with carbohydrates and fat with either (but not combined.) Followers consume about 1500 calories daily. This program falls under low-calorie diets, is low in nutrients and protein and can cause bloating, diarrhea and fluid loss.
 
A Final Word about Fad Diets: Avoid Them!

Avoid fad dieting. You now know that fad diets are counter- productive, and may harm you. You also know that a performance-nutrition plan must be designed to meet specific energetic and metabolic requirements of athletic individuals. For example, a marathon runner requires much less protein then a powerlifter does. By knowing this little bit of nutrition science, it is easy for you to understand that some of the common fad diets have absolutely no use for athletes. Do not get caught up in the myth that surrounds the marketing of various gimmick diets. If you need to lose weight, see your doctor, follow the guidelines in Units 19 through 21, or follow another plan your doctor may prescribe. Recent scientific studies report that the most important factors for losing and maintaining weight include not overeating; eating a low-fat diet (less than 25% of your daily calories) with high fiber, moderate protein and high carbohydrates (mostly from low-glycemic index foods that are also high in fiber); eating whole foods; eating 5 or more smaller meals/snacks per day; and regular exercise.

Under a doctor's supervision, however, some obese people may be put on a very low-calorie diets (less than 1000 calories per day). Most obese people have a hard time losing weight because they have developed a condition known as "insulin resistance," and they may not be able to exercise. When insulin is not working properly, low-carbohydrate diets, are sometimes indicated until the patient begins to lose weight, at which point they return to a low-fat, balanced diet. In some cases, doctors have to use drugs to facilitate weight loss. This extreme dieting depletes glycogen stores and causes adverse effects on physical and mental performance.

In addition to extreme, medically-supervised diets, a new procedure known as stomach stapling has become an option for some clinically obese clients. Stomach stapling, known clinically as gastric (relating to the stomach) bypass surgery, is a type of surgery in which the stomach is reduced in size by one of several methods. The smaller stomach is then reconnected to the small intestine, bypassing the duodenum and other segments of the small intestine, thus decreasing the patient's ability to absorb nutrients from food.

After a gastric bypass surgery, the stomach is reduced from approximately one quart to one ounce (a mere two tablespoons!) This limited stomach capacity can help speed weight loss by making it difficult to eat too much food at one time and to feel satisfied after a very small meal. Because the body strives to maintain a steady state, it adapts to this new, limited capacity. Over time, the stomach pouch will stretch until it can hold between five and eight ounces, or approximately one cup at a time. Gastric bypass surgery is usually performed only after many other alternatives have failed. Remember, these clinical weight loss approaches have no applications for fitness and athletics. So avoid them, unless otherwise advised by your healthcare practitioner.
 
Back
Top